Let’s stop blaming schools for ‘soft suspensions’!

A recent Sunday Age article argues that ‘soft suspensions’ contributes  to youth crime or at least inhibiting rehabilitation of young offenders.  In this post I want to look at the reasons for soft suspensions are occurring and what we can do to reduce them.

What is are soft suspensions?

A soft suspension occurs when the school persuades or encourages a child (sometimes via the parent) not to attend school. Therefore, there is no written record of an exclusion from school, but the child is effectively excluded from school.


Stop blaming schools!

I work in a range of private and government, mainstream and Special Assistance Schools in Victoria. The overwhelming number of schools do their best not to exclude young people. Of course, there are exceptions but that is what they are i.e. exceptions not the rule.

The Balance

School principals must balance the safety of other students and the right of students who are challenging to an education. This is getting more difficult given the evidence that disruptive behaviour is on the increase in Australian schools. A recent Senate inquiry into disruptive behaviour reported that Australian schools ranked 33 out of the 37 OECD countries ie Australian students were more disruptive than students in 34 other countries.

Suggested criteria for whether a whether a soft suspension is justified

I start from the premise that soft suspensions are inevitable as principals cannot always achieve the above-mentioned balance. Therefore, we should not set the criteria as whether soft suspensions occur or not but rather focus on whether the school has done all that is possible to achieve such a balance.

In the following posts, I will outline  some ways that schools can achieve this balance with compromising student/staff safety and the rights of ‘challenging’ students to an education.