Can you fake empathy?


I was recently conducting a trauma informed training program for teaching staff at a Special Assistance School. Clearly empathy is a key skill when working with traumatised young people. A participant asked: ‘can you fake empathy?’ What a great question!


Like any a good psychologist, my answer is both ‘yes ‘and ‘no ‘. Let’s look at the ‘yes ‘side first.
Working with traumatised young people can be physically and mentally exhausting. Expecting staff to respond empathetically in every interaction is unrealistic. Therefore, if on the occasion the empathy is ‘put on’, it may not matter because the young person will interpret this interaction in the context of all previous interactions. If these interactions have been empathetic then they might not notice the ‘put on’ and, even if they do, then it an opportunity for the teacher to repair the relationship eg ‘You are right. I am not at my best today and have a lot going on. I apologize’.

On the reverse side if you are consistently faking empathy then there is little doubt that the young person will detect this and act accordingly. You are also probably in the wrong job!

Finally, we are not modelling reality to young people if we are authentic 100% of the time. We all need to understand that those who care about us can have bad days.